Monday, November 16, 2026

Torahism: A Review

Recently I've read R. L. Solberg's book, Torahism. In it he argues by using traditional replacement theology that Gentile Christians are not required to obey the law of Moses, but that they are welcome to if they wish.

For the past year and half, I have been diving into Torah observance (my preferred term), and began attending a messianic community with a Jewish rabbi and have been studying in a weekly Torah club with material written by FFOZ. I'm in the thick of what Solberg is writing about, and I have questions and doubts as I walk this journey. So my hopes were high that Solberg might present a nuanced refutation of my new path that would challenge me and help me think and grow. Sadly, it was full of the same dated arguments that everyone on this journey has already heard and rejected.

First, I'd like to thank Solberg for engaging in debate in a Christ-like manner. He is respectful, kind, and maintains that Torah-observant people who affirm a "biblical understanding of the gospel" can be called "brothers and sisters in Christ" (pg 5). He even goes so far as to say that, "there is a spectrum of thought on the role the Law plays in the life of a Christian, and I'm convinced there is room for honest disagreement." Bravo.

Second, his conclusion that Gentile believers are not required to obey the law of Moses is in harmony with many Torah observant groups and teachers, such as First Fruits of Zion, David Lancaster, and Michael Brown. These messianic groups hold that Gentiles are invited to Torah, but not required to perform laws particular to Jews (such as kosher laws, and the feasts). I believe Solberg's real targets are within the Hebrew Roots Movement, such as Nehemiah Gordon and others who treat all written Torah as required for life, and even at times deny the role Yeshua plays in redemption. Solberg also takes issue with those who ridicule and mock Christmas and Easter celebrations. Fair.

Why am I so disappointed with Solberg's case? Because it is so weakly argued. It could have been informed by the New Perspective on Paul, but it wasn't. He could have been careful to separate between written Torah command and the "traditions of the elders", but they are all lumped together as "Torahism". This flat reading of scripture has no nuance and it is probably why he has never seen, "anyone being argued out of the Hebrew Roots movement" (pg 43). If you are trying to convince people that revere the tetragrammaton so much that they will not say it out loud, why would you put it in print and speak it in your audio book? And if you are trying to convince people that believe the real way to pronounce the holy Name, is XYZ, then why do you use the academic reconstruction? The real reason Solberg isn't convincing anyone is that it is obvious that he isn't on this journey with us. He doesn't feel the draw to Torah. We are on exhibit, and he came to the zoo for a few visits to look in through the glass and then wrote a book about his visit. Sorry, not cutting it. 

Solberg might contend that he was attempting to write on an accessible level and did not want to burden a lay audience with advanced seminary debates. I get that. Solberg is a gifted communicator and speaks and writes very clearly. One does not need to abandon clarity, however, to embrace nuance. David Instone-Brewer's short book, Moral Questions of the Bible, is a better alternative reading of scripture, with an articulate method of interpretation/application that is different than the modern Torah movement. And it is just as simple and accessible, if not more so. Instone-Brewer is also steeped in ancient Jewish literature and is an authority on topics such as the Mishna and how rabbinic interpretation changed after the destruction of the temple. 

The only authority Solberg rests on is replacement theology. It is very old. Solberg quotes a lot of scripture. All of it is quoted through this theological lens. Instead of arguing why that lens is better than the Torah movement's lens, he just asserts traditional interpretations. These are the same interpretations of the early church fathers, who are rife with prejudices and antisemitism rampant. At one point he uses an analogy that Sabbath observance is like going back to Egypt instead of going forward to a fuller Sabbath rest in the Promised Land. Is it? Doesn't the one complement the other? Isn't the one a microcosm of the other? The false dichotomy of the metaphor is so contradictory, it is annoying on a logic level. Why do those who are married wear a wedding ring? Don't they have the reality? Why wear something that is merely a symbol? The only real valid argument Solberg has is the that's-how-we've-always-done-it argument. Nineteen hundred years of tradition is a compelling piece of evidence with which we must wrestle.

And there is one glaring inconsistency. On the one hand he argues that the ceremonial requirements of the Torah have been abolished in the New Testament era by the work of Jesus. Wouldn't this be true for all believers, both Gentile and Jewish? Yet he holds (correctly) that Jewish believers might have a special, "calling to maintain the boundary markers of their Jewish identity by keeping Torah" (pg 85). If your arguments for abolishing the commands of Torah are universal and based on replacement theology, then there is no space for a special calling for the Jewish people. It is an inconsistency. And it is a valuable one. To be fair, Solberg's thinking is still in flux over this red pill. It is the pebble in the shoe that suggests that replacement theology is wrong. If there is still a special calling to keep the Torah for at least some, than it has not been abolished yet. It is also why Gentile missionary efforts to Jews has been ineffective for two millennia. You know that Torah, the Torah that the most devout and upright among you respect? Yeah, its optional (or discouraged, or even forbidden). That's not winning anyone.

So let's talk about what is "required?" Are Christians required to pray? To attend church services? To tithe? Based on what? What about singing in a worship service or fasting? None of these are requirements in the sense that Solberg suggests, required "for salvation." Yet all of them are encouraged and supported and preached about. Why? They are Christian disciplines and they promote growth in our relationship with God. They don't merit us a cent. But life without them is hard and even meaningless. Did we "get saved" by Jesus to sit at home and "be saved"? No! We are reunited with God and so relish in all of the manifestations of a living relationship with God. My big problem with Solberg's approach is that he asked the wrong question. If observing Sabbath, and Kosher, and the Biblical feasts grows us in our spiritual journey and connects us with God, how are they any different than any other Christian discipline? And why wouldn't we encourage them just the same? But we don't and that is the problem.

I would like to propose a middle ground between the "none of law is required" and the "all of the law is required" camps. Sometimes I call it the "heart of God" approach. Sometimes I call it the "Spirit of the Law" approach. Every written Torah law has a purpose, and aim, a point. Most of them are obvious. Some, not so much. I will call this the "spirit" of the law, much like what we might call its "principle". A good example is the law to build a parapet (railing) around the roof of a house (where roofs were flat and people would walk) in Deut 22:8. The strongly implied intent is plain in this case, God cares about the well being of those in our homes, and expects us to take safeguards to protect human beings. I may not have a flat roof that is a floor of my house, but the heart of God has not changed. The expectation of God has not changed. God cares about those who transverse my property. I think this law has direct applicability to shoveling snow from the sidewalk in front of my house in the winter. Maybe my heart doesn't care about those who pass by, but God's heart does. Regardless if the intent of a law is known or unknown, I believe all written Torah laws show the heart of God, and display His character, and educates us on morals that are higher than our world and culture. While the letter of the law may not apply to any of us, the spirit or principle behind every law certainly does. It is our obligation to pursue the intent behind the law, to study it, and to practice it.

But let's take this a step deeper. Are Christians required to not murder? What about not slandering or lying? What about theft? What about sexual immorality? Are avoiding these required? For salvation? None of these commands are required for earning salvation. Because no command earns salvation (it never has in either Testament). In this respect, Christianity has no requirements either. Jesus' "commands" are wise instruction for living full life and pleasing God once we already are saved. So I take issue with Solberg's question, 'is the Law of Moses required'. It's like a new convert asking, so how many services do I have to attend? It is the wrong question. In the same way, asking how little of the Hebrew Bible do I have to follow to avoid God's wrath, is the wrong question. 

But I'm being harsh and absurd. I do think there are requirements. There are commands in both covenants. They are not prerequisites to get into the covenant, but they are "required" to remain in good standing in them. Not murdering doesn't make me right with God or earn me a spot in the covenant. Persisting as a serial murder, however, would certainly get you ejected. There is a simple analogy for this in the modern world, college. When a student attends college, classes may have prerequisites and assignments. You can't take Calculus II until you pass Calculus I. But even after you get into Calculus II, there are assignments which are required. There are no prerequisites for us to approach God other than belief and repentance. There are no Torah prerequisites in faith. Only assignments and coaching given as requirements after we become enrolled students. 

Continuing the analogy, Jesus has gotten us accepted into the academy on high, and even paid our tuition, which we could never have afforded. Now that we are enrolled in the halls of heaven, there are classes to attend, and books to read, and reports to write, because that's why we are here, to have fellowship with God and live life with Him. If we sleep all day and party all night, it was one big waste of time and someone else's money. So let's roll up our sleeves. Because there is much work to do, and much to learn. None of it is a burden, and all of it is joy. 

2 comments:

  1. Fantastic assessment! I loved the pastoral analogies that help readers connect with the nuances. This was accessible, fair, and intellectually charitable towards our friend Solberg. :)

    ReplyDelete